Other Minds by Peter Godfrey-Smith

Sue Cartwright • 11 July 2022

Fall in love with the intelligent wit and charm of the octopus

Other Minds by Peter Godfrey-Smith - Book Review by Sue Cartwright, Spiral Leaf

As I read this remarkable book, I found myself falling in love with the octopus. It's true and something I did not expect. The more you learn about these immensely expressive animals with their friendly curiosity and mischievous characters, the more endearing they become, and you just can't help wanting to know more about these amazing creatures.

It's a superb read throughout. A philosophy book, as well as a book about animals, biology, science and evolution. Peter masterfully explains the history of animals, carefully walking you through the logic to reveal some stunning facts about how we all came together. He traces the steps from the behaviour of the first single cell organisms to the invention of eyes, through to the branching of vertebrates and invertebrates, to the origination of perception and so on.

When it comes to specific studies of the octopus such as the way they can recognise individual human beings, their awareness of captivity, their mischievousness and other complex behaviours, their food preferences, their tenacity and engagement with novel objects, it's just simply amazing. And I have named only a few of their incredible attributes.


Godfrey cites philosopher, Stefan Linquist, who once studied octopus behaviour who said: 'When you work with fish, they have no idea they are in a tank, somewhere unnatural. With octopuses it is totally different. They know that they are inside this special place, and you are outside it. All their behaviours are affected by their awareness of captivity.'

I am grateful for the knowledge shared by learned scholars of nature like Peter Godfrey-Smith, a professor of history and the philosophy of science. His book is a joy to read when presented with such candour, integrity and humility. Those who study nature make it possible for others to grasp the incredible findings they assimilate, so that we can appreciate the wonders of our natural world in ways we could not achieve on our own.

This brilliant work is no exception. Peter's love for the oceanic world and all those who live there shines through as the sun shines deep into the ocean. When we can all understand the incredible life that has evolved in our deep seas over millions of years, we can start to make better collective choices and efforts to protect and cherish its many precious and fascinating life forms.


Sue Cartwright

Spiral Leaf



Spiral Leaf - Buy the book - Other Minds by Peter Godfrey-Smith

Buy the book!

Purchase a copy of this charming and eye-opening book by following the affiliate link to the Spiral Leaf bookshop below.

Other Minds: The Octopus, the Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness


Thank you for sharing!

 for you, for me and for Mother Nature

Latest Posts

A poem about the Full Harvest Moon and Blood Moon Eclispe
by Sue Cartwright 7 September 2025
A poem about the Full Harvest Moon when we celebrate all we have achieved and take in the energy of the Blood Moon
A post about the healing benefits of Chamomile
by Sue Cartwright 3 September 2025
A post about the healing benefits of Chamomile, a herb that teaches gentleness and brings about a sense of calm
Dates and inspiration for things to see and do in September
by Sue Cartwright 1 September 2025
An Almanac guide to Nature in Setpember with things to do and watch out for at the beginning of the Autumn season
A book review about the cookery book Nourishing Traditions and the wisdom of a healthy balanced diet
by Sue Cartwright 27 August 2025
A book review about the cookery book Nourishing Traditions and the wisdom of adopting a healthy balanced diet
A poem about the energy of the New Harvest Moon in Virgo
by Sue Cartwright 23 August 2025
A poem about the fluid and calming energy of the New Harvest Moon influenced by the earthy grounding of Virgo
A post about the culinary and medicinal value of Cayenne Pepper
by Sue Cartwright 20 August 2025
A post about the culinary, nutritional and medicinal benefits of the hot and fiery spice known as Cayenne Pepper
More posts

All Posts

A poem about the Full Harvest Moon and Blood Moon Eclispe
by Sue Cartwright 7 September 2025
A poem about the Full Harvest Moon when we celebrate all we have achieved and take in the energy of the Blood Moon
A post about the healing benefits of Chamomile
by Sue Cartwright 3 September 2025
A post about the healing benefits of Chamomile, a herb that teaches gentleness and brings about a sense of calm
Dates and inspiration for things to see and do in September
by Sue Cartwright 1 September 2025
An Almanac guide to Nature in Setpember with things to do and watch out for at the beginning of the Autumn season
A book review about the cookery book Nourishing Traditions and the wisdom of a healthy balanced diet
by Sue Cartwright 27 August 2025
A book review about the cookery book Nourishing Traditions and the wisdom of adopting a healthy balanced diet
A poem about the energy of the New Harvest Moon in Virgo
by Sue Cartwright 23 August 2025
A poem about the fluid and calming energy of the New Harvest Moon influenced by the earthy grounding of Virgo
A post about the culinary and medicinal value of Cayenne Pepper
by Sue Cartwright 20 August 2025
A post about the culinary, nutritional and medicinal benefits of the hot and fiery spice known as Cayenne Pepper
A Healing Spice (Paprika) by Sue Cartwright, Spiral Leaf
by Sue Cartwright 17 August 2025
A post about the healing spice Paprika with its gorgeous colour that adds pop, spice and flavour to many a savoury dish
A post about the highly valued culinary and medicinal healing powers of Black Pepper
by Sue Cartwright 13 August 2025
A post about the highly valued culinary and medicinal healing powers of an exquisite spice once known as Black Gold
A poem oabout the spiritual meaning of the Full Sturgeon Moon and the impact of Aquarius on our rela
by Sue Cartwright 9 August 2025
A poem about the deep reflective energy of the Full Sturgeon Moon and the influece of Aquarius on our relationships
A poem about the energy of a powerful planetary alignment of Lions Gate
by Sue Cartwright 8 August 2025
A poem about the energy of the powerful alignment of planets and stars on the 8 August known as Lion's Gate
Show More